Banner
Views: 737,617,376
Time:
8 users online: BaduhxD, BTD6_maker, Deakula, Hiro-sofT, LEcrOse, MarioFanGamer, TheIgnition, tuhmapoika - Guests: 32 - Bots: 192Users: 38,803 (1,932 active)
Latest: rocketfire
Tip: If it's possible to carry a tileset-specific sprite (such as a Buzzy Beetle or Bob-omb) through a pipe, make sure it has the correct graphics and sprite palette on the other side!Not logged in.
Super Mario World Central Idol 4 - Voting (READ CAMERIN'S POST ON PAGE 2!)
Forum Index - Sunken Ghost Ship - Old Contests & Events - Super Mario World Central Idol 4 - Voting (READ CAMERIN'S POST ON PAGE 2!)
Pages: « 1 2 3 4 5 » Thread Closed
Vote here after reading the Discussion Thread

DON'T VOTE IF YOU ENTERED A SONG KTHXBAI!

Big fat edit from Camerin: Read this post!
http://bin.smwcentral.net/u/4803/IdolVoting1.zip

Okay, we're now at the time everybody has been waiting for! Each user will vote for their favorite .spc and their least favorite 6 in the pack of 14 .spcs I have. The order will matter only in that in the case of ties.

Example: the user who was selected first in least favorite 3 times will lose to the user who was selected first in least favorite 2 times and and second 1 time.

This is a slight change from the originally planned method, but I find that this is a better idea and will prevent a massive tie for last place.
Counterfeit // FIRE AND FORGET [~]
(CCCP:~) counterfeit% cat чики-брики.txt
1. Taking Over The Halberd.spc
2. hoohoo.spc
3. Kirby's Adventure - Grape Garden.spc
4. lolmexican.spc
5. Pain The Universe.spc
6. Where Cacti Grow.spc
7. Holy Land.spc
8. MMVII - Intro Stage.spc
9. Beat Them Up!.spc
10. marisaw3.spc
11. DKC3 - Northern Kremisphere.spc
12. gray.spc
13. GerudoValley.spc
14. DKC_TreetopRock.spc
✪ ✪ ✪ ✪ ✪
~ COU/NTERFEITGTX460 ~
Gentoo Linu/x userEx-Sta/ff
Overcaffeinated/My Anime_ List
I AM SILLY_2A Supporter
Gosh, this was tough. There were only a few that I really disliked.

1. Gerudo Valley
2. Hoohoo
3. MMVII - Intro Stage
4. Marisaw3
5. Lolmexican
6. Holy Land
7. Where Cacti Grow
8. Northern Kremisphere
9. Beat Them Up
10. Pain the Universe
11. Kirby's Adventure - Grape Garden
12. Gray
13. Taking Over The Halberd
14. Treetop Rock

--------------------
Mario's Vanilla Journey

Progress: 22/72 levels complete
Favourite
hoohoo.spc

Least Favourite
DKC3 - Northern Kremisphere.spc
DKC_TreetopRock.spc
Where Cacti Grow.spc
GerudoValley.spc
Beat Them Up!.spc
lolmexican.spc
SMWC's official dentist since 2011.

YouTube - Twitter
rule change :

1. Kirby's Adventure - Grape Garden.spc
2. hoohoo.spc
3. Pain The Universe.spc
4. marisaw3.spc
5. Taking Over The Halberd.spc
6. Beat Them Up!.spc
7. Holy Land.spc
8. GerudoValley.spc
9. lolmexican.spc
10. gray.spc
11. Where Cacti Grow.spc
12. MMVII - Intro Stage.spc
13. DKC3 - Northern Kremisphere.spc
14. DKC_TreetopRock.spc
Favourite:
Taking Over The Halberd.spc

Least favourite:
MMVII - Intro Stage.spc
marisaw3.spc
GerudoValley.spc
Pain The Universe.spc
DKC_TreetopRock.spc
DKC3 - Northern Kremisphere.spc

--------------------
Twitter account

Steam Community profile
1. Kirby's Adventure - Grape Garden.spc
2. DKC3 - Northern Kremisphere.spc
3. Taking Over The Halberd.spc
4. marisaw3.spc
5. Pain The Universe.spc
6. gray.spc
7. MMVII - Intro Stage.spc
8. Holy Land.spc
9. Beat Them Up!.spc
10. hoohoo.spc
11. lolmexican.spc
12. Where Cacti Grow.spc
13. GerudoValley.spc
14. DKC_TreetopRock.spc
GvS @smwcentral.net ~ u:11380
Favourite
Holy Land.spc
Least favourite
1. DKC_TreetopRock.spc
2. GerudoValley.spc
3. lolmexican.spc
4. marisaw3.spc
5. Pain the Universe
6. hoohoo.spc

Close call on the first place, meh.
Favorite:
Kirby's Adventure - Grape Garden.spc

Least favorite:
DKC_TreetopRock.spc
GerudoValley.spc
marisaw3.spc
Where Cacti Grow.spc
lolmexican.spc
hoohoo.spc
Edit: Go to this post! Rule changed.

--------------------
Are you an ASM coder and want 20$ on your Steam, PS4, or Xbox One accounts? Private Message me for details.
(I also offer SMW Custom Songs in exchange for ASM! I don't do ports though unless it's to remix.)

Want progress on 100 Rooms of Enemies: The Nightmare Edition? Go here to see.

Are you a sample porter and wanna help with 100 Rooms of Enemies: The Nightmare Edition? Private Message me or Mellonpizza for details.
Favorite:
Mega Man Zero 4 - Holy Land ~ Area Zero Camp

Least Favorite:
Donkey Kong Country - Treetop Rock
Donkey Kong Country 3 - Northern Kremisphere
lolmexican
marisaw3
OOT - Gerudo Valley
Pain the Universe
Note Ihave next to none musical experience whatsoever.

Favourite:
Grape garden


Least Favourites:
DKC - Treetop Town
Gerudo Valley
marisaw
where cacti grew
DKC - Northen Hemisphere
lolmexican

--------------------
Please don't send me PMs about why JDCGames is down. That part of my life is over.
Favorite:
Holy Land

Least Favorite:
Donkey Kong Country - Treetop Rock
Gerudo Valley
Pain the Universe
Where Cacti Grew
lolmexican
MMVII - Intro Stage
Let's do this.


Favorite:
hoohoo.spc - my god this is beautiful

Least Favorite:
Treetop Rock
Grape Garden
Pain the Universe
Where Cacti Grow
Theme of Gray
Gerudo Valley

So many good songs... so many porters I feel really guilty about having to vote down. #w{=(}

--------------------
Now with extra girl and extra hacker
Favorite:
Holy Land

Least Favorite:
Where Cacti Grow
GerudoValley
lolmexican
hoohoo
DKC_TreetopRock
gray
marisaw3
1. hoohoo
2. lolmexican
3. Taking Over The Halberd
4. Pain The Universe
5. Beat Them Up!
6. Kirby Adventure - Grape Garden
7. MMVII - Intro Stage
8. Holy Land
9. gray
10. DKC3 - Northern Kremisphere
11. marisaw3
12. Where Cacti Grow
13. GerudoValley
14. DKC_TreetopRock
I decided to rank all of them just for the heck of it. It was hard, though, even harder than just picking out seven.

*Favorite*

1. Pain The Universe - I like it. Channels 0, 4, and 5 in particular seem well-done. Why didn't you use #6 instead of #4, though, since it's only 6 channels? Actually, on that note, you could probably have used all 8 channels and made it a bit fuller, since it's from a 32-bit game. Still, though...it sounds like a great dramatic boss theme.

*Middle-ranked*

2. Northern Kremisphere - Sounds very accurate.
3. Taking Over the Halberd - Pretty dang accurate, I'd say.
4. marisaw3 - Not bad. (But for Pete's sake, why don't you guys title your SPCs something more descriptive?! It's a good thing I've heard of Super Marisa World....)
5. hoohoo - Sounds all right. Again, though, give the SPC a better freaking title. Not everyone has played these games.
6. lolmexican - Sounds good, although I wouldn't have known what the original is if I hadn't asked. How was I supposed to find it? I can't exactly search "lolmexican" on YouTube...I should dock you points just for that.
7. Grape Garden - Sounds good. I take it this is a 16-bit remix using samples from a SNES Kirby game?
8. Theme of Gray - Sounds accurate from what I can tell, although not that memorable of a song.

*Least favorites*

9. Where Cacti Grow - Sounds okay, but awfully repetitive...is this a custom composition?
10. Gerudo Valley - Sounds okay, but could use a few more channels (for instance, the "clap" sounds are completely missing).
11. MM7 intro stage - Sounds...okay, I guess, but unless you're specifically trying to make a remix, what's the point in sampling music from a SNES game and then not actually using samples from the same game? (Especially when you have BRR samples to work with.) I think the loop is also off.
12. Holy Land - Sounds good, but the echo buffer overflows, so...there you go. If you use an echo delay of 6, you have to set the echo buffer start address to $2500 or less.
13. Beat Them Up! - Sounds good, but sample 26 overlaps the echo buffer. (Yes, it's possible to screw that up even in AddmusicM.) So I really can't not put this one on the least favorite list.
14. Treetop Rock - Way too empty. The original used all 8 channels; this one never uses more than 3 at once.
Favorite
Taking Over The Halberd

Least Favorite
1. lolmexican
2. DKC_TreetopRock
3. GerudoValley
4. Beat Them Up!
5. MMVII - Intro Stage
6. Where Cacti Grow
C3 Thread (2013)

Wow, a lot of great compositions this year.

My 6 least favorites:

1.) Treetop Rock (Definitely the weakest port)
2.) Gerudo Valley
3.) Northern Kremisphere
4.) lolmexican
5.) Where Cacti Grow
6.) Holy Land (It was difficult to choose this last one.)

And my favorite:

Beat Them Up! (I had a little difficulty choosing between this and hoohoo.spc)

--------------------
I no longer have interest in SMW Hacking as I did when I first started several years ago.
Pages: « 1 2 3 4 5 » Thread Closed
Forum Index - Sunken Ghost Ship - Old Contests & Events - Super Mario World Central Idol 4 - Voting (READ CAMERIN'S POST ON PAGE 2!)

The purpose of this site is not to distribute copyrighted material, but to honor one of our favourite games.

Copyright © 2005 - 2019 - SMW Central
Legal Information - Privacy Policy - Link To Us


Total queries: 25

Menu

Follow Us On

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Affiliates

  • Talkhaus
  • SMBX Community
  • GTx0
  • Super Luigi Bros
  • ROMhacking.net
  • MFGG
  • Gaming Reinvented