Banner
Views: 695,415,971
Time:
2 users online: westslasher2, Cookie Zombie - Guests: 13 - Bots: 162Users: 36,368 (1,518 active)
Latest: AmericanLeatherJackets
Tip: Ask the author for permission before ripping graphics from their hack.Not logged in.
Why were the mm2wood.mid and Flintstones theme ports rejected?
Forum Index - Valley of Bowser - Moderation Questions - Why were the mm2wood.mid and Flintstones theme ports rejected?
Pages: « 1 »
The reason listed on the removal log for mm2wood was basically "nice, what if i reject this, itll be epic"
That is literally what it says, go check
And the Flintstones theme just vanished; the only place I saw it was from a snapshot of the site in the Wayback Machine from 2016.
Do they still exist in an insertable form? Can I at least find mm2wood anywhere? Why in the world was mm2wood rejected for such a dumb reason? And how did Diagonal Mario 2 acquire it for use?
mibulls sailcloth blindsight lifeline anan rectipetality faultlessly offered scleromalacia neighed catholicate
I actually talked about this on the Youtube upload of the mm2wood port that I made, but if you want to know, they were rejected simply because, well, they were shitpost ports and nothing else; I can at least vouch for myself, since I only did that for funsies, however I'm sure Pinci did the same thing too

if you want to find a link to those ports, maybe a mod might have a copy of them; just be aware that it wouldn't be very wise to use them, since they weren't meant to actually be used lmao
Layout by Mathos
Originally posted by Ultima
I actually talked about this on the Youtube upload of the mm2wood port that I made, but if you want to know, they were rejected simply because, well, they were shitpost ports and nothing else; I can at least vouch for myself, since I only did that for funsies, however I'm sure Pinci did the same thing too

if you want to find a link to those ports, maybe a mod might have a copy of them; just be aware that it wouldn't be very wise to use them, since they weren't meant to actually be used lmao



No, the very reason I wanted to use them was BECAUSE they were jokes. mm2wood is one of my favorite meme songs. And going by that logic, wouldn't the We Are Number One port be removed too? And how do I ask a mod?
mibulls sailcloth blindsight lifeline anan rectipetality faultlessly offered scleromalacia neighed catholicate
It doesn't seem like much effort went into the mm2wood port. The SPC in the player shows that there's no panning, no echo, no custom ADSR, and the song just flat out ends in sudden silence at 1:16 (although I suppose the original doesn't have a definitive loop point either huh?).

mm2wood rejection log ← if anyone else want to see for themselves.

Originally posted by FailSandwich
And going by that logic, wouldn't the We Are Number One port be removed too?

The We are Number One port is both well-made and a joke. That's just me though.
SPC Thread
Originally posted by Giftshaven
It doesn't seem like much effort went into the mm2wood port. The SPC in the player shows that there's no panning, no echo, no custom ADSR, and the song just flat out ends in sudden silence at 1:16 (although I suppose the original doesn't have a definitive loop point either huh?).

mm2wood rejection log ← if anyone else want to see for themselves.

Originally posted by FailSandwich
And going by that logic, wouldn't the We Are Number One port be removed too?

The We are Number One port is both well-made and a joke. That's just me though.


Kinda harsh commentary here, but yeah, that's pretty much it lol tfw no one noticed me using the thunder sample as a clap tho, which was way before I ever did it on my Idol 9 Round 3 port

Honestly, if I wanted I could have just done a proper mm2wood.mid port, but at the time I did make it I wasn't that experienced with porting yet; now tho... who knows. Don't get your hopes up tho

Also lmao, that WANO port has some pretty wonky pitch bends at some parts, especially when the vocal parts come in; then again I can kinda see why, since the MIDI Wakana used would be very hard to arrange anyways, but still
Layout by Mathos
Oh, sorry if that came off as harsh. Also, I was wrong about there being no custom ADSR. I didn't notice there was a @13 in there at first. #w{=D}

The point that I was trying to make was that joke ports don't get rejected solely because they are memes. I do find it strange though that the rejection log for this particular port didn't have any proper advice or feedback.
SPC Thread
Originally posted by Ultima
Originally posted by Giftshaven
It doesn't seem like much effort went into the mm2wood port. The SPC in the player shows that there's no panning, no echo, no custom ADSR, and the song just flat out ends in sudden silence at 1:16 (although I suppose the original doesn't have a definitive loop point either huh?).

mm2wood rejection log ← if anyone else want to see for themselves.

Originally posted by FailSandwich
And going by that logic, wouldn't the We Are Number One port be removed too?

The We are Number One port is both well-made and a joke. That's just me though.


Kinda harsh commentary here, but yeah, that's pretty much it lol tfw no one noticed me using the thunder sample as a clap tho, which was way before I ever did it on my Idol 9 Round 3 port

Honestly, if I wanted I could have just done a proper mm2wood.mid port, but at the time I did make it I wasn't that experienced with porting yet; now tho... who knows. Don't get your hopes up tho

Also lmao, that WANO port has some pretty wonky pitch bends at some parts, especially when the vocal parts come in; then again I can kinda see why, since the MIDI Wakana used would be very hard to arrange anyways, but still


In my opinion, an mm2wood port would not only be good for joke hacks, but it would also fit for a castle theme in an ordinary hack. I have been wanting an mm2wood port that I could actually use for SO LONG that I tried to learn to port music for the sole purpose of porting mm2wood. It sounded really bad, though. So I
do hope someone does make an mm2wood port someday. Until then, I guess I'll stick with We Are Number One for my castle theme.
mibulls sailcloth blindsight lifeline anan rectipetality faultlessly offered scleromalacia neighed catholicate
This sounds like mm2wood to me.
Pages: « 1 »
Forum Index - Valley of Bowser - Moderation Questions - Why were the mm2wood.mid and Flintstones theme ports rejected?

The purpose of this site is not to distribute copyrighted material, but to honor one of our favourite games.

Copyright © 2005 - 2018 - SMW Central
Legal Information - Privacy Policy - Link To Us


Total queries: 23

Menu

Follow Us On

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Affiliates

  • Talkhaus
  • SMBX Community
  • GTx0
  • Super Luigi Bros
  • ROMhacking.net
  • MFGG
  • Gaming Reinvented