END OF GAME
NIGHT ACTIONS
- Prizm, the Doppelgänger, wakes up and copies underway's Drunk role. He becomes the Doppelgänger-Drunk. Then he swaps his card with Center Card C, the Alpha Wolf. Prizm joins the werewolf team. Since he obtained a werewolf role due to the Robber and NOT the Doppelgänger, he doesn't get to wake up when the werewolves do. This means he doesn't get to see if there are any other wolves, and the other wolves don't get to see him.
- Impetus, the Mystic Wolf, wakes up alone. Despite being a werewolf, Prizm doesn't wake up. Impetus looks at Center Card A (the Witch) and, believing she is a Lone Wolf, looks at K3fka's card (the Aura Seer).
- BlackMageMario, the Apprentice Seer, looks at Center Card D and sees the Center Wolf.
- J_128, the Robber, chooses not to rob anyone.
- MarioFanGamer, the Troublemaker, swaps the cards of Falconpunch (Revealer) and underway (Drunk).
- K3fka, the Aura Seer, sees that Prizm, Impetus, BlackMageMario, and MarioFanGamer have all looked at or switched cards previously in the night.
- underway, the Drunk, swaps with Center Card D, becoming the Center Wolf and joining the werewolf team.
- Falconpunch, the Revealer, looks at J_128's card and sees the Robber.
- RanAS (the Tanner) and The Koopa Resistance (the Bodyguard) slept soundly through the night.
PLAYERS AND ROLES
Impetus:
Mystic Wolf
Prizm:
Alpha Wolf
underway:
Center Wolf
BlackMageMario:
Apprentice Seer
Falconpunch:
Drunk
J_128:
Robber
K3fka:
Aura Seer
MarioFanGamer:
Troublemaker
The Koopa Resistance:
Bodyguard
RanAS:
Tanner
Center Card A:
Witch
Center Card B:
Minion
Center Card C:
Doppelgänger-Drunk
Center Card D:
Revealer
VOTING RESULTS
BMM: 7 votes
Falconpunch: 1 vote
K3fka: 1 vote
underway: 1 vote
Quoteunderway: BMM
Impetus: BMM
BMM: Falconpunch
MFG: BMM
TKR: BMM
Falconpunch: BMM
RanAS: K3fka
Prizm: still BMM
K3fka: BMM
J_128: underway
With 7 out of 10 votes, the town starts to lynch BlackMageMario, but The Koopa Resistance--the
Bodyguard--protects him from being lynched. With no other majority (at least two votes are required to lynch), the town is unable to lynch anyone.
Werewolves win!
COMMENTS
Yes, none of the werewolves knew who the other werewolves were. However, near the end of the day phase Prizm told me in query that he was 99% sure underway was Center Wolf. +1 point to Prizm.
There are a number of things I'm surprised nobody caught. For starters, nobody really doubted Impetus's Witch claim at all, even though at the start I specifically mentioned it's possible that nobody has Witch.
The crux of the game was Prizm's claim that BMM was the Alpha Wolf. There were two things with this claim that should have been pointed out but weren't:
- Prizm stated he was able to use the ability of the Apprentice Seer that he got from Drunk. He passed it off as being tired and it was never mentioned again. However, if he had actually grabbed Apprentice Seer from Drunk, and therefore was town, he would have had no reason to say he used its ability in the first place. The mistake he made because he was tired was that he made an easily falsifiable claim; he made up a claim in general because he was a werewolf.
- If Prizm's claim was correct that BMM was Alpha Wolf, that means that somebody else was Center Wolf. Instead of simply stating back and forth "I am not" "You are too", players could have determined if anyone else was acting suspicious and used that to confirm or deny Prizm's claim.
Prizm had the opportunity to legitimately claim (Doppelgänger-)Tanner and
he didn't do it.
Nobody took TKR into account. He had the power to save BMM as the Bodyguard (a claim which went uncontested), and stated flat out that he believed Prizm was lying and BMM was the Apprentice Seer. From that point on, it would have been best for the town to ignore the BMM/Prizm argument altogether and look for another possible wolf, but everybody ignored his post.
I would have posted my mistakes with Drunk and Witch even if both roles had started in the center.
To underway, who deleted the PM saying what role Drunk claimed in order to fix my mistake: I couldn't tell you why I still posted the mistake because it would reveal to you that there was a Doppelgänger-Drunk.