Banner
Views: 864,829,584
Time:
21 users online:  brickblock369, BWGLite, Doug Walker, Drippz85, EvilGuy0613, ExxorD, FYRE150, K.T.B.,  LMNtals, MaxwelHacks,  Nameless, Nonesuchriver, PokerFace,  Sinc-X, smwpatch123, Splat3r,  Stivi,  Teyla, TokZone, Valkyria, ZMann - Guests: 48 - Bots: 74 Users: 47,889 (2,070 active)
Latest: Larry457
Tip: Use the Iggy/Larry Battle Tools to edit Iggy/Larry's platform.Not logged in.
A simple request - view all of a particular user's reviews
Forum Index - Valley of Bowser - Site Questions & Feedback - A simple request - view all of a particular user's reviews
Pages: « 1 »
When browsing the hacks available on this site I often see reviews that seem better-written and more in-depth than the others. I consider high-effort reviews and/or reviews by experienced level designers to be better indicators of hack quality than simple average scores and the like. Is it possible for the site to implement a function that allows users to view all of a particular user's hack reviews in one place?

--------------------
Erstwhile TheCowDestroyer / TheIncredibleCowDestroyer.
Briefly coming out of lurking to say yes, I would like to see organized pages of hack reviews too. About a year ago, I was trying to take hack reviewing more seriously, but I had trouble figuring out the best way to format my reviews, so I wanted to search for other reviews for inspiration. Well, it's not easy to find reviews buried within hundreds of comments.

Another idea coming to mind would be a separation of review/comments. If you are familiar with how MFGG does reviews on their fangames, they have a separate "review" and "comment" section for each fangame, which seems to work fine.
This thread is a better fit in site questions and not SMW hacking so I'm going to move it.
Wasn't there a page that displayed reviews from all resources? Or am I missing something?

Either way, a page to view a particular user's reviews would be sweet, just like with submissions.

--------------------
Twitter
Originally posted by Katerpie
Wasn't there a page that displayed reviews from all resources? Or am I missing something?

Not one that I can find. It is possible that a given user's reviews may be visible in the section of their profile that displays all of their forum posts, though that would be immensely cumbersome as a way of viewing a person's reviews.

--------------------
Erstwhile TheCowDestroyer / TheIncredibleCowDestroyer.
Yes, it's possible to dig through a user's posts to look for posts of theirs that review hacks. But while it's not coded, you'll have to satisfy yourself with that.

--------------------
Twitter
Pages: « 1 »
Forum Index - Valley of Bowser - Site Questions & Feedback - A simple request - view all of a particular user's reviews

The purpose of this site is not to distribute copyrighted material, but to honor one of our favourite games.

Copyright © 2005 - 2020 - SMW Central
Legal Information - Privacy Policy - Link To Us


Menu

Follow Us On

  • YouTube
  • Twitch
  • Twitter

Affiliates

  • Super Mario Bros. X Community
  • ROMhacking.net
  • Mario Fan Games Galaxy