Language…
14 users online: Gamet2004, katun24, Larabee, LinkVideo64, MDBattleFrog, metronia, OEO6, pandapand, Saela, Space_Pig,  Tahixham, wye, yogui, Zavok - Guests: 81 - Bots: 270
Users: 55,722 (2,328 active)
Latest user: pandapand

Reviews or Comments?

Link Thread Closed
I noticed that some hacks are already recieving one-sentence "reviews." This is kind of annoying. I thought the whole point of renaming "comments" as "reviews" a few months ago was to encourage mult-sentenced reviews, not unspecific comments like "I liked your hack." Could we have a rule stating that only descriptive reviews should be allowed in the hacks section? Good reviews are a useful way to decide which hack to play next.
There could be a minimum word requirement or something.

But I agree, people ask/answer questions and whatnot, something that should be done somewhere else for sure.
Originally posted by Supertails
There could be a minimum word requirement or something.

But I agree, people ask/answer questions and whatnot, something that should be done somewhere else for sure.

QFT, A reveiw sould be a reveiw, not a comment.
Originally posted by Supertails
But I agree, people ask/answer questions and whatnot, something that should be done somewhere else for sure.


Yeah, asking questions in the review area is also annoying. Questions should be asked in the Hack Discussion forum.
Hacks should be reviewed by B.B.Link.

Comments are nice, but dosen't give specific details.

Originally posted by Lulz
"O hai ter, your hax is awsume. kthnxbai"
Originally posted by Orbis
Hacks should be reviewed by B.B.Link.

Or by people who've been part of the site, long enough to know how things work around here.

Hell, I wouldn't mind reviewing some hack, since I critique alot. :P
Your layout has been removed.
Originally posted by Orbis
Hacks should be reviewed by B.B.Link.


(thumbs up). But now i'll have to play ALL the hacks here, and i'll be a hated critic, ouch -_-.

Maybe I could hire an Elbert to my Roper while we go through these hacks together. Who's wants to try it?
Originally posted by B.B.Link
Who's wants to try it?

Hell, on my vacations and I have no social life.

So, i'd like to help you, B.B. I don't mind playing through 20 glitched up hacks :P.
Your layout has been removed.
I have a lot of free time. I could play through the hacks and submit reviews... I've already played a lot of them anyway.
Either one of you just PM me when you're ready, and i'll tell you where to start.
Reviews done by experts? Great idea! Now that we've reached a sensible conclusion, this thread can be closed.
I wrote two reviews for SDW:TLC and SMI1, I should copy those over from the old... thing.

Closed... by request... I guess.
Link Thread Closed