Originally posted by bored2tearsB.B. Link.... no requests are impossible... it just takes a lot of time.... so
anyway... then I request the weird mushroom screm thing from sonic and knuckles in mushroom hill zone...
Can I ask why you don't just use SonEd to make your own sonic game, since 90 percent of the things you want are from Sonic anyway? I'm not trying to be rude; I'm just honestly curious because I don't get it. If you want to make Mario in "Sonic Land," why not just edit Sonic's graphics to appear like Mario? Neither game's mechanics are very similar to one another, vs. basic platformer characteristics, so I just don't see the point in cramming 95% of Sonic into SMW, instead of just putting 5% of Mario into Sonic.
And, you're right, most requests aren't impossible, but don't expect someone else to spend 10-20 (or more) hours coding something hugely complex and that won't even probably work that well in actual use. Plus, who's to say all that work will be worth it? Who's to say the person who requested it won't just bail on this site, their hack, SMW hacking in general or die in real life? Why waste the time if it's not worth doing?
I mean, if something so complex is so vital to your hack, then why not take the time to learn it yourself? I'm not just talking to you, bored, but to everyone. Is it really that great making a hack if you just did the level design, but everyone else did the GFX ripping and boss creation for you? For something like that, the others deserve the credit more than the creator, in my opinion.
I really appreciate the fact that Bio made this new thread (obviously, since he quotes me in the first post). I think it should be telling to everyone that he hasn't added any extra requests so far.
We've already got 30 posts in a two-day-old thread. In a month, we'll be back where we started - a bunch of junky requests and very little accomplished. I mean, I can see the "cool" factor in many of the requests here, but I can't see the necessity.
The only request not touched so far that I would like to see come to be is Troopa Pride's Jumping Goomba, so I'll go ahead and put a second in for that, if it adds any incentive for someone to look into it.
Also, if someone who knows some ASM would be willing to help me, I would love to learn some fairly simple routines so that I can personally edit some custom sprites to tailor them to my liking. I'd be very willing to share most of my results. Just PM me if you think you can help.
Also, what would be the best place to request specific help with smaller sprite-editing projects like this? I assume this isn't the place, but I also don't know where would be.
[?] Miscellaneous Helpful Hints
If I moderated your hack, there was apparently a 90 percent chance it was rejected.
