Of course you don't have proof; we don't have any proof of anybody being anything, because none of the power roles are going to claim due to the guy floating around with a protection-bypassing kill. At this point, I believe McCarthy is running off of his two snoop results, which are apparently mafia results since he would be stupid to throw out random names when the town could have literally lost last night and
the night before that.
If this is the case, McCarthy hasn't been the only one going off of results. I am the Postmaster General
. Night 2 the person I checked received a result stating someone's role, and a PM later I figured out that person was the Federal Investigator. He then revealed to me who the Poll Meister and Secret Service Agent are.
The remaining town roles all have night actions, so if I get a player-didn't-send-PM result (which I did) then the person I checked is very
likely mafia. There is that small chance that I check a town role who is inactive or something, but if that's the case at this point then the town doesn't stand a chance anyway. I'm merely waiting on a PM from the Investigator (Seriously guy, where is it?) to confirm my suspicions, then I'll post my results in the thread.
Originally posted by Medic
I'd suggest we vote for Delta again, it's been working out. How about you just send him a PM with who you think the mafia is.
I'd actually heavily advise against
voting Delta. Remember, the Propaganda Officer has a convert that may or may not have been used. Killing off a member of the mafia to gain the trust of the town is a very legitimate tactic when the mafia can deal with one fewer member, and the possibility of converting a town member who was clearly judge last round is even better since the Federal Investigator can't figure out whether someone is converted or not.
Voting someone to be judge again because he blindly went with McCarthy's accusation is a bad strategy since nothing has cleared him (see logic above).
Meanwhile, I'm actually claiming to have evidence
, which I also said (in this post) that I would post in the thread when I can confirm it. There's no reason not to vote for me unless you're mafia and trying to throw people off.