Banner
Views: 854,502,762
Time:
24 users online: AnasMario130, anonimzwx, bersi, binavik, Bruno_Peixoto, Carld923, chickaDEE Magazine, Connnnair, Exodustx0, Ezek.The Square Remixer, FelixHappyGamer, Golden Yoshi, Green Jerry, I don't know a good name.,  KevinM, lx5,  Ninja Boy, obersteiner86, pat94plus,  Pinci, PixusPanic, slopcore, WhiteYoshiEgg, Zidan3 - Guests: 76 - Bots: 65 Users: 47,168 (2,476 active)
Latest: DogShades
Tip: Check this thread for a list of SMW sound effects.Not logged in.
Mafia Revival - Sign Ups
Forum Index - Donut Plains - General Discussion - Forum Games - Mafia Revival - Sign Ups
Pages: « 1 2265 266 267 268 »
MM9 you made a huge slip. How could you know the mafia had a roleblocker? In the case where they would fakeclaim doctor, they wouldn't have one. All we knew before BMM died is that a cop was in the setup. That is it. Not a roleblocker or a doctor.

If the mafia didn't have a roleblocker, they would have known there was no doctor in the setup but it'd be a safe claim because there was no way anyone in the town could prove the setup didn't have a doctor, and nobody would counter claim it.

BMM definitely wasn't clear or confirmed as doctor as you keep saying.
Originally posted by Latukas
MM9 you made a huge slip. How could you know the mafia had a roleblocker? In the case where they would fakeclaim doctor, they wouldn't have one. All we knew before BMM died is that a cop was in the setup. That is it. Not a roleblocker or a doctor.

If the mafia didn't have a roleblocker, they would have known there was no doctor in the setup but it'd be a safe claim because there was no way anyone in the town could prove the setup didn't have a doctor, and nobody would counter claim it.

BMM definitely wasn't clear or confirmed as doctor as you keep saying


Quote the part of my reply when I said he was confirmed Doctor. I said he was uncounterclaimed and very likely the real Doctor.

I didn't make any slip up, there IS a mafia roleblocker in play which we know NOW that the Cop and Doctor or dead. Obviously we didn't know this when the Doctor claim was still debatable, but again, quote the part of my reply where I said we could have known there was a roleblocker back in that Day round (hint: I never said that.) You're twisting my words around to make me look guilty. Next time you say that I said something, I'd appreciate it if you quoted it, if only for context.

Also kind of funny how ShadowFire didn't immediately vote for you. Maybe he's a bit hesitant because the two of you are mafia and he doesn't want to lynch his fellow mafia member? If he was mafia and you weren't he'd have won the game if he voted for you.
Originally posted by MajorasMask9

Because the mafia falseclaiming doctor would have been a bad play. Obviously the mafia knew there was a Doctor alive when EvilGuy died and was revealed as the Cop (since they have a Roleblocker, meaning Row 2 roles were used.) By falseclaiming Doctor there would be a Doctor counterclaim by the real Doctor, and even if we lynched that doctor, we'd have a confirmed guilty player since we would then know he wasn't the Doctor. I really don't think it would be like you for you (as a townie) to vote for someone who's claiming Doctor of all things.

And your vote wasn't just a countervote. You voted for him after you "saw him slip up" and you latched at that piece of evidence hard. As if you no longer cared that there was a possibility he was the Doctor.


This. You completely missed my point from both rounds.

You say "By falseclaiming Doctor there would be a Doctor counterclaim by the real Doctor"

As I've said repeatedly (and I'm really confused as to WHY you've glossed over this point twice now, because I'm pretty sure you know how this setup works) last round, the only role confirmed was the cop. The mafia didn't HAVE to have a roleblocker at that point. Until BMM died and was revealed as the cop, there were two possible setups. (which I even mentioned at the start of the round, "either Townie + Cop + Mafia Goon, or Mafia Roleblocker + Cop + Doctor.").

In the former possible setup, the mafia would have KNOWN there was no doctor, so no, there would not be a counterclaim by the real doctor. In that case, BMM could be Mafia claiming doctor (as doctor is a possible role) when in the actual setup, no doctor exists.

As the town we're unable to prove that claim true or false, regardless of if its uncounterclaimed. Which brings me back to my point of it being 50/50. And as BMM was acting scummy, it wasn't an unfair bet.

So yeah there is your slip up basing that entire claim on the mafia having a roleblocker, and then blaming me for voting BMM on the premise that there were apparently no other possibilities at that point.

Apollo's death is also an annoying WIFOM situation. Also hey, you're right why hasn't the mafia killed you by now? Of course, that goes for everyone else too. I expect if you're scum you just made that turnaround because Lightvayne voted for me. If he isn't your partner anyway. I don't really know at this point.
Originally posted by Lightvayne
I'll admit that I was a bit irritated and tired yesterday. I would still like to at least try and make the town win.

Voting For latukas


Wait, has this come into question yet? Why did Lightvayne suddenly decide to go for Latukas when he said he was going to vote for himself earlier? It also feels that MM9 just glossed over that fact of LV being scum earlier.

Originally posted by MM9
That leaves ShadowFire and Lightvayne. I'll admit, I do think Lightvayne could be mafia, but I think it's likely he's a townie. That leaves Latukas and ShadowFire.


What about Lightvayne made you think he was a townie?

--------------------
Later.
@Latukas: I'll concede that I was getting a bit ahead of myself there, but are you really going to try to argue that the Doctor claim was worth lynching over? I think it was obvious BMM was just confused about certain points, but you made his mistakes into "fatal mafia slip-ups." While the possibility of the mafia claiming Doctor because they could have known there wasn't one existed, BMM really didn't seem particularly scummy (IMO anyway) and lynching a doctor claim is very risky. It just seemed like an unnecessarily risky move by you which is what I found out of character.

@ShadowFire in regard to Lightvayne: Because him voting for himself would be bad, and would cost the town the game? Did you really want him to follow through on that? And like I said, I originally was suspicious of Lightvayne, but by the end of the last Day round I became less suspicious of him, even less so in his replies after that round. I mean look how hard he was pushing to get people to be active in the last day round. I'd think a mafia member would LOVE inactive players being around.

As to why I think he's a townie, mostly gut feelings. Why do you think he's guilty?

EDIT: And I know that I can't exactly use me being innocent as evidence when I can't even prove that I'm innocent, but I really do think eXcavator is innocent because of his inactivity. From my perspective that means the mafia likely consist of two of Latukas, ShadowFire, and Lightvayne. Considering Lightvayne voted for Latukas and ShadowFire didn't hammer the vote to end the game, I think it's likely Latukas and ShadowFire that are mafia. Not exactly expecting this to convince anyone, but just explaining why I might have a bit of a bias toward thinking Latukas is guilty.
Argh. I'm really sorry guys, being sick + having AP tests has given me a major perma-headache for the past week and I haven't really been able to think much about this game. Just reading over the previous votes, to be really honest a lot of people really look kind of suspicious right now, give me some time to gather my thoughts and I'll have a vote.
Bump.
A little more than 1 day before deadline.

--------------------
woag.....

(previously superdragonyoshi1. sup yall.)
Well, better vote MajorasMask9. Him and LV must be the mafia because neither ShadowFire or eXcavator has hammered on me.
And this is the predictable part where Latukas and ShadowFire vote for an innocent person at the last minute.

Would like to point out to eXcavator when he gets back that if Latukas were a townie he would have been on top of this day round (we mislynch we lose, and we have to lynch.) Instead he stalls, and ShadowFire will likely come in and vote with him at the last minute. They're very clearly mafia so I hope you see this and vote for Latukas.

EDIT: Typo

EDIT2: A quick summary of the biggest reason why I think Latukas and ShadowFire are mafia, for eXcavator when he gets back:

*If Lightvayne was mafia he would have either killed me in the night or voted for me. Yesterday I intentionally drove the point home that I would definitely vote to kill him today. In the night, Apollo said that if she dies, that we should vote for me. When she died, Lightvayne voted for Latukas. If he were mafia why hasn't he done anything to me yet?

*Further, Lightvayne has been actively trying to promote activity. If it wasn't for him telling Apollo and I that the game was going on, we'd probably have missed Day 2. He would have a lot to gain by having inactive players, kind of like Latukas and ShadowFire do now. I think it's safe to say Lightvayne is a Townie.

*There are three townies alive in the game. If you (eXcavator) are a townie, which I assume you are, then that means that between me, Lightvayne, Latukas, and ShadowFire, there are two townies. While there's obviously a "chance" that Lightvayne is mafia, if you agree with my earlier points that he's a townie, that means that between me, Latukas, and ShadowFire, there are two Mafia. Under that implication:

*If Latukas is the Townie: He has two votes, one by me (Mafia) and one by Lightvayne (Townie). This can't be true though because that would mean ShadowFire was mafia, and he would have hammered the vote to lynch Latukas and win the game.

*If ShadowFire is the Townie: That would mean Latukas is Mafia and I am Mafia. We are both the only two players with votes on each other. If we were smart, we'd push to kill Lightvayne, not each other.

*If MajorasMask9 (me!) is the Townie: That would mean Latukas and ShadowFire are both Guilty. Lightvayne (Townie) and I (Townie) have two votes on Latukas (Mafia), and Latukas has a vote on me. ShadowFire (Mafia) will likely come in and vote for me, tying the vote. Otherwise they'll lose.

The only one of those three that makes much sense at all is the last one. Throw this all on top of the fact that Latukas has been a pretty scummy player and I think it's obvious he's mafia with ShadowFire.

EDIT 3: SHOOT I DIDN'T EVEN NEED TO WRITE ALL OF THIS
I could very well be wrong, but I'm going to go with my instincts on this one and side with MM9. Voting Latukas.
Dang.

Yeah my bad for forgetting you're good MM9. I probably should have killed you last night. Would have been easy to lynch Lightvayne then...


also I haven't played mafia in months also stop making me mafia jegus I can't remember the last time I was town anymore
voting Latukas

--------------------
Later.
Night 3

Latukas was lynched. He was the Mafia Roleblocker.
Night round. 24 hours for PMs.

--------------------
woag.....

(previously superdragonyoshi1. sup yall.)

Haha. Awesome. Eat that mafia :V
Layout by LDA during C3.
Day Four GAMES ENDS HERE

Majorasmask9 was killed. He was a vanilla townie.

Lightvayne -
Shadowfire -
eXcavator -

Day round will last 48 hours. 2 votes to a lynch.
I assume that's all you'll need?

--------------------
woag.....

(previously superdragonyoshi1. sup yall.)
MM9's logic for Lightvayne being town is pretty solid, I'm willing to go with it. Goodbye, ShadowFire.
voting eXcavator

--------------------
Later.

uh...well then...guess its down to me.

Gonna coin flip this one and go with.....ShadowFire
Layout by LDA during C3.
(my fault for being late with this deadline)

Well you guys lynched shadowfire.
Good thing he was the remaining mafia goon.
Town wins...even though there are only 2 people left alive in the town...

Mafia. It happened.
Okay next game (unless you guys are sick of it)

--------------------
woag.....

(previously superdragonyoshi1. sup yall.)
I said this before but I think ShadowFire rather gave me away.

Also SDY1 are you offering to host for the next game too? Else does anyone else want to host?

(I think that last game went pretty well) (yes this post is a sign up if anyone hosts)
Pages: « 1 2265 266 267 268 »
Forum Index - Donut Plains - General Discussion - Forum Games - Mafia Revival - Sign Ups

The purpose of this site is not to distribute copyrighted material, but to honor one of our favourite games.

Copyright © 2005 - 2020 - SMW Central
Legal Information - Privacy Policy - Link To Us


Menu

Follow Us On

  • YouTube
  • Twitch
  • Twitter

Affiliates

  • Super Mario Bros. X Community
  • ROMhacking.net
  • Mario Fan Games Galaxy