Language…
11 users online: AppleBoy54321, Eduard, FrozenQuills, grassodocia53, kuroki, Mr. MS,  RussianMan, Scags, SJandCharlieTheCat, Squiggs, thekiller678 - Guests: 91 - Bots: 273
Users: 56,284 (2,255 active)
Latest user: Astrotraveler_07

Mafia Revival - Sign Ups

  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 78
  • 79
  • 80
  • 81
  • 82
  • 83
  • 84
  • 85
  • 86
  • 87
  • 88
  • 266
  • 267
  • 268
Originally posted by superdragonyoshi1
15:54 <SF> i will tell you im mafia
15:55 <SF> nuff said
15:55 <SDY1> alright

Obvious vote of Shadowfire.
All this took was the expense of revealing my role, so hurr.

I'm not too sure I entirely believe you. Are you sure that SF is mafia? Has he actually told you, or did you fake it for whatever reason?

If you did fake it, one must wonder why. The main reason I suppose is possibly to hide your own mafia identity. Obviously, saying another person is mafia could lead the town of your trail. However, I'd reckon this will be a bad choice immediately after the person - presumably innocent - dies. The town would then have suspicion towards you because you either lied or were mis-informed.


If you were telling the truth, this would make more sense. However, I must ask how you received this important information. Do you have a role - Sheriff, for example - that permits you to do this; or did you find out through the IRC? If you are the sheriff, then won't the mafia try to kill you tonight? Unless a first aider, such as myself, saves you, you may die tonight, assuming your possible role claim is correct. Sadly, First Aiders are not reliable as doctors for curing town members.



So in conclusion, we have to evaluate your claim to decide whether you are telling the truth or not. I guess that's upto you to decide. However, I believe - through instinct - that SDY1 is lying for some reason. I will not change my vote though, until I hear a counter argument.




Anyway, why is everyone voting Devann? Am I missing out on something here?
Don't forget though - it doesn't matter who was telling the truth in the quote. We know that either SDY1 or SF are mafia,or possibly both of them.
Originally posted by JDC
Anyway, why is everyone voting Devann? Am I missing out on something here?
Don't forget though - it doesn't matter who was telling the truth in the quote. We know that either SDY1 or SF are mafia,or possibly both of them.

It's a random vote. We're killing people whose roles we don't have any idea about, hoping to kill The Moon. As long as The Moon is alive, the game will be stuck in an infinite loop of no progress.

If ShadowFire is mafia, then there's no point in killing him because unless the moon is killed he'll come back to life in a day or two anyway. Thus, making the vote a waste to begin with.
Originally posted by MajorasMask9
Originally posted by JDC
Anyway, why is everyone voting Devann? Am I missing out on something here?
Don't forget though - it doesn't matter who was telling the truth in the quote. We know that either SDY1 or SF are mafia,or possibly both of them.

It's a random vote. We're killing people whose roles we don't have any idea about, hoping to kill The Moon. As long as The Moon is alive, the game will be stuck in an infinite loop of no progress.

If ShadowFire is mafia, then there's no point in killing him because unless the moon is killed he'll come back to life in a day or two anyway. Thus, making the vote a waste to begin with.


That's a valid point, but we need to find out who the moon is before we can make any progress or throw out any random votes.
Originally posted by JDC
That's a valid point, but we need to find out who the moon is before we can make any progress or throw out any random votes.

We need to find out who the moon is, yes, but you agree that on the first day we can't get any information right?

If we kill one person at random, there is a chance that they are the moon.
If we no-kill, then no one dies, making it less likely that the moon will die in three days.

Right now, I think even the mafia would agree that the moon is top priority to be killed, and the more people that are killed, the more likely it is that we'll find the moon.
Originally posted by Me in IRC
16:56 Shadow-Fire now, i have a theory
16:57 Shadow-Fire ok
16:58 Shadow-Fire everybody is random voting, hoping to find the moon by off-chance
16:58 Shadow-Fire that is a good idea, since they could come back when link plays the song of time, and not vote them that time
16:59 Shadow-Fire however, that depends on a few things
16:59 Shadow-Fire if link has any brains at all, he will play the song of time at the last day
16:59 Shadow-Fire if he has no brains, he wont
16:59 Shadow-Fire i dont expect that to happ
16:59 Shadow-Fire en
17:00 Shadow-Fire but, with the random voting
17:00 Shadow-Fire there is an equal chance of killing link, as the moon
17:00 Shadow-Fire if link dies, no song of time
17:00 Shadow-Fire 3 days remaining, and nothing more
17:01 Shadow-Fire everybody will go frantic trying to find infomation
17:01 Shadow-Fire but in truth, unless they DO manage to find the moon, the moon and skull kid
17:01 Shadow-Fire they win
17:02 Shadow-Fire now there are quite a few first aiders
17:02 Shadow-Fire they are going to try and save someone
17:03 Shadow-Fire if they agree with the random votes, they will target someone random
17:03 Shadow-Fire if they dont, they will target the votee
17:03 Shadow-Fire saving them, and killing the person who has the second most amount of votes
17:03 Shadow-Fire which i think is me
17:04 Shadow-Fire now i know everybody wants to find the skull kid and moon more then mafia
17:04 Shadow-Fire I know that for a fact.
17:04 Shadow-Fire if they didnt, according to what SDY1 said, i'd be screwed
17:05 Shadow-Fire so yeah
17:05 Shadow-Fire i might post this in the thread


this is my theory of the game. we have an equal chance of killing link(and we'd be screwed if we do) as the moon. still voting Devann, since i dont think he is link., but take that theory into consideration.
Later.
You people are idiots.
I mean, you people are SERIOUSLY IDIOTS.
That's fine though. You vote me off, I'll 100% guarantee the bad guys win. I'll 100% guarantee it.

I've never been wrong.
You're making a fatal mistake.



GOOD JOB VOTING OFF A GOOD PERSON OUT OF RANDOMNESS AND IGNORANCE! GOOD JOB! YOU'LL NEVER GET ANYWHERE LIKE THIS!


On a serious note, voting no-kill. This is senseless.
I also suggest the rest of you do the same.
Yes, we have equal chance lynching Link as we do at lynching the moon. Regardless, I see no other good course of action. What would be better, then, if you disagree with our methods?
Originally posted by bigbadbabysitter
Yes, we have equal chance lynching Link as we do at lynching the moon. Regardless, I see no other good course of action. What would be better, then, if you disagree with our methods?



..............no-kill.................
I'm voting No-Kill again. Our Zelda will help us this night. I hope he finds out Majora.
Originally posted by Delta
I'm voting No-Kill again. Our Zelda will help us this night. I hope he finds out Majora.

How could I have missed this for so long?! Arg!

Anyway, I have thought of another critical flaw in the "wait for Zelda" approach. Generally speaking, sheriff roles are not given specific roles, but rather, are given alignment. In other words, if Zelda were to check the moon, all that the person would come up with is anti-town, correct?

Then this further makes your strategy awful. Zelda cannot discover The Moon!
Originally posted by bigbadbabysitter
Originally posted by Delta
I'm voting No-Kill again. Our Zelda will help us this night. I hope he finds out Majora.

How could I have missed this for so long?! Arg!

Anyway, I have thought of another critical flaw in the "wait for Zelda" approach. Generally speaking, sheriff roles are not given specific roles, but rather, are given alignment. In other words, if Zelda were to check the moon, all that the person would come up with is anti-town, correct?

Then this further makes your strategy awful. Zelda cannot discover The Moon!


This is unrelated completely to the matter at hand.
WHAT DID I DO TO DESERVE TO DIE?!?! D:
ADMINS PLEASE MAKE E-MAIL NOTIFICATIONS A THING I BEG OF YOU
Actually, Zelda is a role sheriff. I should of cleared that up earlier.
Nottttt such an idea to wait for Zelda at this point. All we have to do is make sure we don't kill Link, so we can continue this cycle over and over and over and over and over and over

and over and over and over and over and over

and over and over and over and over and over

and over and over and over and over and over

and over and over and over and over and over

forever until we can figure out who Majora's Mask is. (I've actually been playing some of that recently!)
Honestly Devann could be anything, and pulling an early bandwagon on a smart (if somewhat confusing) player may not be the best choice. Unless I'm missing something, if we repeat the cycle everything will be reset, so Zelda will actually get extra checks while still keeping the old ones. It's like the masks.

What would be excellent is if Twinrova could possibly manipulate Majora's Mask to reveal their role. I hope the baddies know that they're against Majora too.....

Anyways, there's my stance on the game so far. Shadowfire is confirmed mafia, so we can kill him when we know exactly what to do.

Oh, and voting No-Kill.
woag.....

(previously superdragonyoshi1. sup yall.)
Originally posted by phenolatukas
If three in-game days pass, Majoras Mask and Skull Kid will win. However, Link is able to PM me at any point in the game, playing the song of time and reseting it to day 1. Be warned... This only works once. In addidtion, dead players will return to life- and role information will NOT be revealed unless Majoras Mask is killed.


Nope, we don't go over and over and over. We only get 6 days max to find Majora's Mask.
We need to kill someone. Anyone that isn't Link will do.

I personally am Rauru, one of the First Aid Sages. I guess I don't really have much evidence to back that up, but you're going to have to trust that I'm not lying.

Unless you people really think stalling out and hoping Zelda gets lucky (oh what is this innuendo) is the best idea? Killing off people randomly helps cut down the number of people that could possibly be Majora's Mask, so no-killing still isn't the best idea.

My vote is still for JDC because why not.
May we meet again outside the battlefield.
At this point I'm reeling between joining the Devann bandwagon or coming up with one of my own, so to hell with it.

Gonna pass out a not-so-random vote of Delta, and see what we can go with after this.
woag.....

(previously superdragonyoshi1. sup yall.)
You know what they say. The uninformed stay uninformed, which is quite literal in this case.
I guess i agree with sdy1(what is wrong with me?! D:) and MM9, no-killing won't get anyone anywhere, we at least need to do something (and Devann is desesperated about no-killing)

So yeah, voting Devann

Vanilla contest entry - Download!




Whoa! I have a Tumblr!

Layout made by me.
Thanks to Leod and algorithmshark for helping.
The 'wait for Zelda' strategy is certainly better than 'random vote and possibly killing Link therefore screwing us over' approach.

My No-Kill vote still stands, as we have no information.
Changing my vote to Derpy Backslide.
  • Pages:
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 78
  • 79
  • 80
  • 81
  • 82
  • 83
  • 84
  • 85
  • 86
  • 87
  • 88
  • 266
  • 267
  • 268