From the SMWCentral image at the top of the site, it looks like the person who did it walked up to the cake backwards and then retraced their steps on their previous steps. And it looks like they drew an M on the cake and then threw it on the floor a little bit.
Hmm, yeah, the footprints definitely have some importance here. If this was a modern-like mystery a la Phoenix Wright, we could analyze those footprints with a forensics expert, but I dont think that`s possible here, is it?
Hello again! First of all, I'd like to thank all of you for taking your time to help me out in this intriguing task. Not to dismiss my own ability of figuring it all out on my own, but you know, even the greatest minds can use some help from time to time. A handful of you even have your final answers packed and sent my way already!
The search hasn't ended yet, however - in fact, I still need to find some time to read all of your answers, and perhaps do some more searching here and there. So you all have until this here forum closes to send me your answers. Even if you haven't signed up yet and you've had a sudden burst of interest in mystery solving, come and post here and I'll add you onto my helpers list!
Wario is always greedy for everything; cake included. He would eat it all. He always has the kind of rivalry with Mario that would encourage him to try to frame Mario for it. 1000% sure of it. Now lets lynch Wario like he was the Mafia.