Banner
The Overworld Design Contest ends in
1 MONTH, 4 DAYS, 15 HOURS, 19 MINUTES AND 4 SECONDS
Views: 897,835,798
Time:
32 users online: Alex No, AmperSam, BreadEater, Dakras Hayashi, Darolac, detdu, Dr.Moe, Earthling, Fintan, Friday_D0nat, Hernan, Impetus, Infinity,  K.T.B., katun24,  KevinM, KiloMinimo, l337f00l, mae_86, Marcozzo Daro, mariusreturns, MaxwelHacks, MercuryPenny, MirrorReflect, mmBeefStew, Nolanator, Nowieso, puyofan99, qantuum, TheRealCatsup,  Thomas, yv64n - Guests: 89 - Bots: 76 Users: 50,375 (2,291 active)
Latest: cal89
Tip: The lowest row of 16x16 tiles in a level do not appear, unless the "Allow viewing full bottom row of tiles" box is checked in the #lm{MARIO69} menu. Be mindful of this when designing levels!
Not logged in.
Discussion and Questions
Forum Index - Sunken Ghost Ship - Old Contests & Events - The 10th Annual Vanilla Level Design Contest - Discussion and Questions
Pages: « 1 2 3 4 548 49 » Link - Thread Closed
Ooookaaay yeaa I completely understand your reasoning now frost. Think about it this way:

A level like "Stormy Ruins" last year, was a level that looked very nice aesthetically and had an amazingly creative use of tilesets.

In the vldc9, this level would have scored highly in both creativity and aesthetics, putting it at an enormous advantage over the other levels. While, levels like Ruins of Cupidity scored low on aesthetics. Ruins looked completely fine though. Who's to say it shouldn't score high in aesthetics?

This category change lets those levels do well in aesthetics, so you don't really need to be a "fabulatory" to score a perfect in aesthetics, actually all you need is a well polished, nice looking level with a decent palette. Now, the creativity part of the scoring means that levels like Fabulatory can be rewarded for being creative with their tilesets, while not having a huge advantage of scoring a perfect in both categories. Fabulatory is very creative in its aesthetics, but not so in gameplay. In this case, it only gets a 15/30 or so in the creativity. However, in the vldc9 scoring, Fabulatory would have scored highly in both creativity and aesthetics, even though the gameplay was not creative.

My question to the judges is, would a level like Ruins of Cupidity only score a 15/30 on creativity, because it doesn't implement aesthetic creativity?
Originally posted by GbreezeSunset
My question to the judges is, would a level like Ruins of Cupidity only score a 15/30 on creativity, because it doesn't implement aesthetic creativity?


That's partly why Creativity's two parts are lumped together, tbh. It's so that people aren't expected to be creative with their aesthetics.
Originally posted by Enjl
I don't really feel like being creative with my entry because for all I know 29 of these 30 points could flow into "aesthetic creativity"."


This needs to be explained.

Aesthetic creativity is when aesthetics are used to reinforce the ideas already in the level. It's not an overflow category for aesthetics, that'd be absurd. It's wholly separate and even levels with not-so-great aesthetics can get points for aesthetic creativity.

Here are two examples from VLDC9:

  • Subterranean Glow is a cave-level filled with cool-looking glowy exanimation, but its aesthetics and its gameplay are entirely separate. It doesn't incorporate the aesthetics into the gameplay at all. This level would have scored high in aesthetics, but the way it used its aesthetics would earn no points in creativity.
  • Gambly Night is a casino-themed level whose aesthetics have been discussed to death (and will not be discussed further). The aesthetics reinforce the theme creatively by implementing harmless chance scenarios in the random pipe section and arguably by the transition to a "dead" section in the ghost-filled secret exit route. Regardless of how well it scored in aesthetics, it would earn a few points in creativity for this.

The most important thing to note is that creativity scores have always been this way. We didn't just start including creative use of aesthetics in that category, it's just that the wording has changed to be more concise. The categories themselves have not changed.
Gbreeze: I actually answered that in my previous post lol

EDIT: nevermind whatever else I had, I misread Frost's post
it's all come down to this.

it's gonna happen.

it's starting now.













Time to win vldcx.

Fite me u posers

--------------------
Later.
kinda iffy on the rubric as well - mostly on the middle 30 (i'm fine with aesthetics being 15-20% of the score as long as design is the other 80-85%). something about the wording and description bothers me.

still, as long as a super well-rounded level wins this year, then it should be fine

edit:

<SNN> like as long as we can collectively look at the top 10 and say "yeah, that's good", then the rubric could be whatever
Lowering the number doesn't make it any less arbitrary lol

--------------------
Can we make our own layer 3 bgs?

--------------------
I do art commissions cheap! PM here or DM via Discord for more details.

**Layout by Erik557


Can we get a chance to make theme levels? If I were you, I could make a Freedom Planet-themed VLDC level.

i hope i win
Puyo Puyo Tetris 2 is available now on ALL PLATFORMS! JOIN THE HYPE TRAIN! And don't forget to discuss the latest happs in this thread and follow @PuyoOfficial on Twitter for updates!
And so the Courier who had cheated death in the cemetery outside Goodsprings cheated death once again, and the Mojave wasteland was forever changed.
“Even if you personally are so dissatisfied with life that you want the world to end, surely the cruel reality is that it will continue on, unchanging. All the better for someone perfectly content, like me.”
Aya Shameimaru, Touhou Suzunaan ~ Forbidden Scrollery
Originally posted by Ruberjig
Can we make our own layer 3 bgs?


yes

Originally posted by kamekku14
Can we get a chance to make theme levels? If I were you, I could make a Freedom Planet-themed VLDC level.

i hope i win


yes?

--------------------
GitHub - Twitter - YouTube - SnesLab Discord
If you can do the theme within the restrictions of the contest, then sure, go for it.
Originally posted by Ruberjig
Can we make our own layer 3 bgs?

Yes, you're allowed to make your own layer 3 backgrounds. But keep in mind that a layer 3 background requires two ExGFX files: a 2KB file for the graphics and an 8KB file for the tilemap.

Originally posted by kamekku14
Can we get a chance to make theme levels? If I were you, I could make a Freedom Planet-themed VLDC level.

You can make whatever theme you want as long as it fits the rules of the contest. Go for it.
Oh crap, I forgot to ask, I may have misread the rules on recoloring? So no custom palettes?

--------------------
I do art commissions cheap! PM here or DM via Discord for more details.

**Layout by Erik557


Recoloring is not the same as changing palettes. Palette editing is completely free. Recoloring refers to making a tile use different colors in a palette.
I have to say, the part I love the most about this contest is the site theme. Absolutely loving scrolling the site with this theme. Also huge congrats to Magiluigi. That's probably one of the best banners I've seen in a while!
I'm noticing the current level threads all have level numbers.
Do we need to claim a specific level number?

--------------------
Signed,
-LuigiTime
No, it was needless the last years as well. It was just one person started it and then more people followed without thinking.

--------------------
Your layout has been removed.
Originally posted by leod
without thinking.
no i thought about it

--------------------
It was a holdover from vldc 7
Simply for the fact that there will be more levels translevels (levels you enter from the overworld) than SMW has, you likely don't.
It was a thing in VLDC7 but was dropped for the later ones because it originally was to be put into two ROMs but due to dropped entries, one actually was enough. The Map16 tiles, sublevels, ExGFX and music slots were also assigned but once again, they got dropped.

--------------------
Okay, my layout looks ugly.
Pages: « 1 2 3 4 548 49 » Link - Thread Closed
Forum Index - Sunken Ghost Ship - Old Contests & Events - The 10th Annual Vanilla Level Design Contest - Discussion and Questions

The purpose of this site is not to distribute copyrighted material, but to honor one of our favourite games.

Copyright © 2005 - 2021 - SMW Central
Legal Information - Privacy Policy - Link To Us


Menu

Follow Us On

  • YouTube
  • Twitch
  • Twitter

Affiliates

  • Super Mario Bros. X Community
  • ROMhacking.net
  • Mario Fan Games Galaxy
  • sm64romhacks