-------------------------------------------- (Title) 11th.spc Accuracy: 4/10 Quality: 18/20 Total: 22/30 Comments: A very high quality remix, and sadly very hard to recognise as a remix of the title theme. It took a few listens for me to recognise, which is why I've put the accuracy down. The chorus end is nearly unrecognisable apart from the descending notes that give it away. Apart from that though, you've managed to work within the limitations of the SMW sound-set to a T. Well done. -------------------------------------------- (Underground) Cave.spc Accuracy: 9/10 Quality: 13/20 Total: 22/30 Comments: An interesting hyperactive remix of the underground theme. The content is faithful to the original with accurate representations of the melodies, though of course the mood has changed to become quite threatening. Personally I believe this would be greatly improved without DnB percussion (sorry) and more variation with the hihat volume to increase when tension rises. With threatening music, in my opinion, you want lots of dynamic range to bring back a mysterious vibe where the listener's attention will perk up when the music is developing. Right now, all of it going on at the same time doesn't work for me. I would like to say that the PWM lead is really cool and fits great! -------------------------------------------- (Athletic) hills.spc Accuracy: 9/10 Quality: 17/20 Total: 26/30 Comments: Really nice remix and quite faithful to the original, cool syncopation added, makes for a more interesting rhythm. My biggest complaint is that the bass is a bit overpowering. I really like the fills in this one. It takes the original theme to a new level and keeps it interesting with multiple listens. -------------------------------------------- (Overworld) mountain2.spc Accuracy: 7/10 Quality: 17/20 Total: 24/30 Comments: I really like the orchestral feel to this; it makes it sounds like a new world, which highlights the adventure that Mario is taking. Overall it encompasses parts of the melody while harmonising the rest to fit with the new mood. -------------------------------------------- (Athletic) smw city.spc Accuracy: 7/10 Quality: 12/20 Total: 19/30 Kinda poor mix in terms of volume levels (maybe because of the echo too?). Some incorrect notes from the referencing of Athletic theme but it's not enough to say it's not accurate as it's mostly harmonisation. Sometimes it skips a little, I'm not sure if that's a valid argument against it though because it might be deliberate. (0:12,0:20,0:36, and then big one at 1:00 and 1:01 where it's almost trying to catch up) -------------------------------------------- (Forest of Illusion) vldc11_smp.spc Accuracy: 7/10 Quality: 15/20 Total: 22/30 Nice remix with a reference to the overworld at the start! Some off notes; nothing too big but it stands out to me personally. Overall a quite nice all-encompassing remix that adds some swing to the original. The added harmony is a bonus. -------------------------------------------- (Athletic) vldc11night.spc Accuracy: 8/10 Quality: 19/20 Total: 27/30 Great smooth jazz remix of the athletic theme with what I believe to be sections of other SMW melodies. It's not afraid to go past referencing to add new interesting harmonies. The mix is very clear and nothing gets drowned out.